Those Who Fall Have Wings

Not available for screening anymore

  1. Extra

    Those Who Fall Have Wings

    Jeder der fällt hat Flügel

    Directed by



    92 min

    • German


    The burden on the chest of asthmatic Kati is too heavy for the shoulders of her four-year-old baby sister. A severe loss and the awakening of Kati's sexuality take their toll on the fifteen-year-old visionary girl. But like a sound that merges into silence, Kati attempts to carry her memories to a place of recurring farewell.


    • Special Jury Prize - Karlovy Vary IFF


    Jana McKinnon
    Renate Hild
    Pia Dolezal
    Christos Haas
    Peter Brunner
    Franz Dude
    Peter Brunner
    Robert Schumann

    Director's Statement

    The passing of my grandmother, the poem Das Spiel ist aus (The Game is Over) by Ingeborg Bachmann and Robert Schumann’s song Ich hab’ im Traum geweinet (I Wept in My Dream) were the starting points for making THOSE WHO FALL HAVE WINGS. It is a film that takes a counter-position to a classic narrative structure where the audience is often deterred by facts and constructions from contributing. We tried to make a movie that used a situation sketch as guideline and not a written script. Instead of rehearsing specific situations or analyzing them I used the preproduction time of THOSE WHO FALL HAVE WINGS to work out parts of the scenes with the actresses, after having worked on their characters and their characters’ backgrounds.

    My concern was to put the performers in a state of awareness and responsibility towards their partners and not to confront them with the situations in the film unless they were on set in their characters. This process was very demanding, I sometimes had to rethink after observing and to adjust the editing in my head, while other knots were untied fruitfully. The improvisation, modification or redesign of some scenes, of course, had an impact on the editing and a “writing in editing” – post-production process was foreseeable. This way of working – to let chance play a role and to trust new ideas that come up during the process of finding a solution within a situation – is not for everyone and not for every film.

    I chose this approach because it is a method that I know from making music and because it reflects the flowing atmosphere and structure of the poem that inspired me. Another key to making the basic feeling of this film come to life – which, for me, is very similar to the pulse of a slow, musical flow in its conception – was the actress Jana McKinnon, with whom I have already worked on My Blind Heart. I am very happy about her courage to swim freely in an unknown water. For Kati is a character that extends herself so far into her memory and expands into such vast times that she almost dissolves in a very fascinating way.

    The other person I owe much gratitude to is my mother, who took on the role of the Grandmother and acted for the first time in her life in front of a camera. Some doors in this film will remain locked to those that do not have the courage to rely on their intuition but cling to the concrete. I refuse to accept that people of today need an instruction manual for everything. Those who insist on that will never see this movie anyway. The basic idea of THOSE WHO FALL HAVE WINGS was always an abstract mood, which is connected to the parting of my grandmother. Six months after her death we shot this movie in her small, cramped house.

    Despite the demanding subject, the low budget and the time limitations, our shoot worked out thanks to our team and its passion founded on our common past and collaboration on My Blind Heart. Each of us knows about bidding farewell. We get to know it already in kindergarten, when we say goodbye to our parents. During the making of this film I learned how difficult it is to find correspondences and ideas for the cinema for describing a person that goes through this phase in different variations and explores it in order to move on. “On” in this case will never be forward, backward, or downward, but will always remain an undetermined direction. For me, this film, this kind of story is a matter of existence. Here you can see what you have, and you do not have much in the end, right?

    Festival Bookings


    Peter Brunner's film seems determined to resist any compromise, delivering its messages in sets of symbols and suggestions that are often repeated.

    Dan Fainaru, Screen Daily

    An impressive and mature performance by Jana McKinnon.

    Fernando Vasquez, Nisimazine

    Peter Brunner

    Peter Brunner


    The body is probably the last cry of mankind in the 21st century.

    Peter Brunner is a Vienna-based filmmaker and musician (Cardiochaos). His work includes short films and music videos, which screened at international festivals all over the world, as well as the feature SICKNESS OF THE YOUTH, which he directed together with fellow students and in which he played the leading role. His feature film debut MY BLIND HEART premiered at Slamdance Film Festival and in the Tiger Competition at IFF Rotterdam 2014 and has won several awards at international film festivals, including a nomination for the Golden Frog at Camerimage Film Festival. THOSE WHO FALL HAVE WINGS won the Special Jury prize at the Karlovy Vary IFF in 2015. His most recent film, TO THE NIGHT (2018), was selected at the Karlovy Vary IFF.

    Selected Filmography